Performance of Steel Buildings against Natural Disaster

Having sufficient knowledge of the latest and applicable design codes and standards enables a structural engineer to prepare cost-effective and safe design solutions for different structures. In essence, structures like concrete and Steel Buildings must be designed to resist the forces applied in various combinations/loading conditions. This is especially true for project sites where Natural Disasters such as storms/typhoons and earthquakes occur frequently.

Four (4) basic load cases are considered when designing Steel Buildings. The first two are predominantly applied along the gravity direction, while the succeeding loads are predominantly applied in the lateral direction. Further explanation of these basic load cases are as follows:

  1. Dead Loads (D)

         Dead loads are loads applied to the structure along the gravity direction. These include the self-weight of the structure (all permanent construction), and other materials permanently fastened onto the structure.

  1. Live Loads (L)

          Live loads are also applied along the gravity direction. These are loads are calculated depending on the structure’s occupancy. Live loads may vary at different locations of the structure. For example, the magnitude of the live load for an office space/room shall be different from that of the storage area of a particular building.

  1. Wind Loads (W)

         Wind loads are a combination of lateral and vertical loads applied to the contact surfaces of the building. Calculation of the wind load for a specific structure considers several factors. The structure’s geometry, the maximum wind speed at the project site, exposure category, gust effect, directionality and topography are just some of the major factors to be considered when designing Steel Buildings.

  1. Earthquake Loads (E)

           Earthquake/Seismic loads are forces calculated due to the seismic events the structure will be subjected to. Factors such as the nearest seismic source, the magnitude of the earthquake, soil type, and the type of seismic force-resisting system to be used are some of the factors to be considered in the calculation of the design earthquake loads for a structure.

Steel Buildings Natural DisasterSteel Buildings Natural DisasterSteel Buildings Natural Disaster

The basic principle of structural design is to select the best section of a structural member that can safely and economically resist the loads applied to it. These loads include various combinations of gravity and lateral forces in accordance with the provisions of the referral code. A structural steel section is considered economical if it can resist loads while maintaining an optimum self-weight (usually expressed in mass per unit length). An optimized self-weight of the section implies that lighter steel sections are required to be fabricated, and effectively lowers the material cost. At present, there are two design philosophies that are being used when designing steel structures. These are the Allowable Stress Design (ASD) Method, and the Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) Method.

In the Allowable Stress Design Method, the steel section to be selected shall have cross-sectional properties (i.e., area and moment of inertia) adequate to resist the maximum applied loads under a permissible value. Applied loads may be in the form of compressive or tensile axial forces, shear forces, bending moments, and torsion. Each form of the applied load is compared to a permissible value of sectional strength.

This permissible value is referred to as the Allowable Strength. The Allowable Strength is defined by taking the Nominal Strength of the steel section and dividing it by a Factor of Safety (FS).

The value of FS varies for different types of loading conditions. For example, the safety factor for bending moment capacity shall be different from the factor of safety for shear capacity of the section.

In the Load and Resistance Factor Design, the sectional strength of a member under failure conditions is considered. The design process under LRFD is done by taking the sum of applied service loads and multiplying it with an individual load factor for each load type. The factored loads are then applied to the structure. Member size selection is determined by calculating for the strength of the chosen steel section and multiplying it by a reduction factor. To illustrate this better, the working principle behind LRFD is expressed as follows:

Factored loads are usually greater than the service loads, thus making the load factors greater than 1.0. The factored strength is always less than the nominal strength of the steel section, thus making the resistance factor less than 1.0.

Steel Buildings Natural Disaster At this point, the discussion focused on the determination of the sectional strength of a structural member. Despite satisfying the strength requirements from the applied loads, serviceability is also an important criterion in determining the right design for a structure. Two of the most common factors to consider in serviceability are the member deflection and the story drift. Depending on the governing design code, the deflection criterion is satisfied by taking the maximum deflection of a structural member due to the applied loads, and comparing it with the allowable deflection prescribed in the code. The allowable deflection is expressed as a fraction of the member’s unsupported length. This fraction also varies depending on the load condition being considered (e.g., D only, L only, D plus L).

Steel Buildings Natural Disaster

The second factor being considered when checking for serviceability is the drift of the structure. Drift is defined as the lateral displacement of the building when subjected to load combinations involving transient loads (wind and earthquake loads). In practice, the drift is calculated at the beam-column joints of the structure, per floor. The displacement of a joint on one story relative to one below it is called the inter-story drift.

For service load combinations involving wind loads, the permissible inter-story drift is valued as H/600 to H/400, where H is the story height. The permissible value is referred from Appendix CC (Serviceability Considerations) of ASCE 7-16 (Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other Structures).

For service load combinations involving earthquake/seismic loads, the seismic inter-story drift shall be not greater than 2.50% of the story height being considered for structures having a fundamental period of less than 0.70 s. For structures with a fundamental period of 0.70 s or greater, the seismic inter-story drift shall not be greater than 2.00% of the story height under consideration. The seismic drift is inelastic in nature due to the inelastic response of the seismic force-resisting system. The inelastic drift is calculated using the following equation:

Steel Buildings Natural DisasterWhere Δm is the inelastic drift, R is the seismic response modification factor, and Δs is the elastic drift. The prescribed drift limits were based on studies that determine the tolerance of both structural and non-structural elements of a uilding against lateral displacements under seismic events.

It is important that safety and economics are considered when designing Steel Buildings of any material type (i.e., reinforced concrete, structural steel, or a combination of both). These two factors should go hand in hand to come up with efficient building designs of varying occupancies. Adequate sectional strength and serviceability limits as prescribed by the local/governing structural codes must be observed by the Structural Engineer, especially for areas frequently struck by Natural Disasters such as earthquakes and strong typhoons. Strict implementation of these referral design codes ensures the optimum performance of the building while maintaining the safety and welfare of the general public.

For expert assistance on your steel building structures requirement, contact our team. You may email us at info@escsteelstructures.com or visit our website https://www.escsteelstructures.ph/ for further information

Application of Structural Steel in Bridges

Structural Steel Bridges exist in significant numbers in every corner of the world. In the United States alone, more than 30% of the Bridges are built with Steel as the exclusive or major component. Steel Application in Bridges are not just strong, durable, and flexible, they are extremely beautiful. Many of them are popular as magnificent attractions, historical landmarks, ‘Nobel Prize’ winners, and valuable architectural masterpieces.

Structural Steel as a solution to extensive bridge projects guarantees lighter and faster construction, innovative designs, socio-economic benefits, and positive environmental effects. As a versatile material, Structural Steel components can be fabricated into limitless formations to cater all bridge types and designs. They can be basically arches, trapezoidal, helical, and more; or maybe in complicated shapes such as a knot, a serpentine torch, and other irregular figures. These materials possess the flexibility to create wonders like the stunning neo-futuristic steel structures we see around us nowadays. Vast application of Structural Steel is evident in different types of Bridges as follows:

Beam Bridges

Application of Steel in Bridge Girder Designed primarily for function and efficiency, this type supports reinforced concrete deck slabs using steel ‘I-beams’ resting on abutments or piers at each ends. There are two types of beam Bridges: multi-girder involving multiple steel beams; and ladder deck – consist ing two steel beams and intermediate bracings. They are suitable for highway Bridges of medium span (13m to 100m). Recently constructed Beam Bridges have decks rigidly connected to the abutments for the purpose of eliminating expansion joints and bearings. Beam or stringer Bridges are the simplest and does not much consider aesthetics.

Box Girder Bridges

Application of Structural Steel Bridge in Box GirdersThis is a type of bridge with beams shaped like a hollow rectangular or trapezoidal box also called the ‘box girder’. A box girder consist two webs joined at the top and bottom by flanges, in some cases it is closed at the top by the deck itself. They are usually built from pre-stressed concrete, Structural Steel, or a composite of steel and reinforced concrete. The cross-sectional configuration of a box girder is ideal for applications requiring good torsional stiffness such curved Bridges and other difficult design cases. Box girder Bridges are appropriate for spans of 100 to 200m using either a single box or more as required. When utilized for lengths of over 200m, they are likely to function as integral part of a cable-stayed or suspension bridge. Photo credit: pinterest.co.uk

Truss Bridges

Application of Structural Steel by Truss DesignLoad-bearing capacity of a truss bridge depends on the framework of its superstructure composed of interconnected steel elements forming triangular units. The purposeful orientation of each individual steel member contributes to the efficiency of the truss to perform in tension, compression, or both as a result of dynamic loads.Trusses also serves as beam or component in composite decks, as arch bridge stringers, as cantilever beams, or as girders to cable-stayed Bridges. They are widely applied in foot-Bridges, demountable Bridges, gantries, and railway Bridges of over 50m span.

Arch Bridges

Application of Sructural Steel in an Arch BridgeA ‘through arch bridge’ is also known as a ‘half-through arch bridge’ or ‘through-type arch bridge’. An arch structure which can be a steel truss, plate box girder, steel I-beam, or reinforced concrete section, supports the bridge deck. The deck can be supported on struts, sit on top of the arch, or suspended from the arch by tension cables. Steel arches act primarily in compression. Variation of this bridge type is the ‘tied-arch’ or ‘bow string arch bridge’. The deck hangs from the arch above it and acts as a tension tie. Arch Bridges are well suited to abridge wide waterways or wherever foundation works are difficult to construct or establish. Aside from being architecturally attractive, these Bridges are relatively cheaper and flexible. Photo credit: en.wikipedia.org

Suspension Bridges

Al Ittihad Suspension Steel BridgeTypical suspended Bridges are built with two steel cables hung between two supports forming a catenary. For short span structures such as a footbridge, the steel cables are replaced with alternative material say an arch steel pipe. The bridge deck is suspended from these cables by a series of vertical high-tension wires along its length. All of the steel cables and hangers absorb tension forces. Suspension Bridges are used as solutions for longest spans. One of the most iconic examples of a suspension bridge is the famous Golden Gate Bridge of San Francisco, USA

Cable-stayed Bridges

Steel Cabled BridgeCable-stayed bridge involves towers or pylons where high-tension cables are anchored to support the deck girder at intervals. The cables or stays run directly from the tower throughout the center or both sides of the deck resembling a fan-like pattern. This type of bridge is an optimum solution for spans longer than Cantilever Bridges but shorter than Suspension Bridges. Recent engineering advances have made it possible to extend the effectiveness of Cable-stayed Bridges up to spans of over 1 kilometer. The anchor towers, which can be in the form of A-frame; H-frame; or a column, works in compression. The deck girders sustain compression and bending stresses.Photo credit: en.wikipedia.org

ESC Group’s ESC Steel Structures division has a global supply capability of heavy Structural Steel bridge products. It is the ESC policy to fabricate and furnish clients with quality products to international standards. ESC has completed major bridge projects around the world – and is an expert in steel bridge girder and arch fabrication.

The types of Bridges within ESC’s capabilities include:

  • Steel highway Bridges
  • Railway Bridges
  • Movable Bridges – eg Bascule, Swing
  • Heavy truss structures
  • Multiple plate girders
  • Trapezoidal box girders
  • Suspension Bridges
  • Steel Arch Bridges
  • Temporary or Modular Bridges
  • Special Bridges

Other components that ESC can fabricate include:

  • Handrails
  • Steel columns
  • Decking Formwork
  • All types of bridge bearings

Should you have a requirement, you may contact our expert. Email us at info@escsteelstructures.com

Safety Aspects of Structural Steel

Structural steel has long been one of the most utilized materials in different magnitudes of many fabrication and construction works.  Steel structures can be an integral part or almost the entirety of Steel Bridges, Pre-engineered/ Prefab Steel Buildings, Offshore Structures, Heavy Steel Fabrication Units, Pressure Vessels, Material Handling Structures, and more.

Roundout pressure vesssel ensuring Safety through inspection
ESC fabricates access chambers for tunneling projects

While studies and discussions have shed light on aspects of cost, strength and durability, and speed of installation, many are still skeptical about the advantage of structural steel in terms of safety.

There are features of steel itself and behaviors as a structure which has positive influence to safety.

Here is to explain some of the most notable among them.

  • Structural steel and reinforced concrete both produce structures that are strong enough to withstand fire, strong winds, heavy snows, termites, and fires. However, steel structures have the most significant advantage over concrete structures when comes to behaving against earthquakes.
  • Besides earthquakes, steel framed structures perform better against natural phenomena such as hurricanes and snow loads, and man-made circumstances like explosions. The extraordinary tensile strength of steel is the reason behind it.
  • Steel is non-combustible and does not ignite nor spread flames. This property helps a steel structure to prevent rapid spread of fire and sudden collapse. Although steel loses strength when exposed continuously to extremely high temperatures, it gives warning as it buckles or deflects before finally crashing. That moment, which can be as fast as a blink of an eye, or a couple of seconds, means everything in a matter of life and death.
  • Steel structures are conductible or well-grounded and are less probable to be hit or damaged by lightning. A steel-framed building permits lightning current to pass harmlessly through the steel members then into the ground. Materials with greater resistance to electricity are more likely to absorb structural damage when struck by lightning. A steel building with a properly installed lightning protection system is safe against that fearsome 1,000,000 volts of electricity.
Erection of a Srtructural Steel
ESC fabricates a pre-engineered building structure for the expansion upgrade of brewery in Papua New Guinea
  • Labor works using steel solutions can be reduced up to over 50% compared to other alternatives. The lesser work force employed at a given project, the lesser lives are exposed to danger. Risks and hazards associated to heavy congestion and traffic at work areas are also eliminated.
  • Pre-fabricated steel building solutions appears to make construction time significantly shorter. The shorter duration to complete a project also means lesser time of exposure to hazards. Pre-fabrication of multiple structural steel elements in controlled environments not only promote quality but minimizes works at heights. Because steel components are delivered to the site as assemblies, minimal number of workers and timeframe is required to finish the installation.
  • Recycling is a process that enhances environmental safety. Steel is the most recycled material at present with at least 80% of its kind generated from recycled products. Steel can be recycled repetitively or can be reused without further processing. Steel is a greenhouse material contributing to not just the safety of a team of workers or a group of building occupants but the planet Earth.
  • Quality assurance check on steel structures is an easier task to perform because all members are exposed and accessible. This is essential when integrity of structures, after occurrence of any kind of phenomena, must be assessed whether capable to safely continue its service or not
Al Ittihad Arch Footbridge - Steel Structure
ESC Steel Structures was contracted by Waagner Biro Gulf Middles East Bridge Divisionfor the specialty heavy steel fabrication of the heavy pipe arch for a new foot bridge over Al Ittihad Road, one of the busiest roads in Dubai.

Steel Arch in Al Ittihad Bridge, Steek Structure

Some experts claim that the overall performance of any building against seismic activity is more a function of design rather than the material used in construction. However, structural steel is obviously becoming a top choice of designers and owners because of its promising properties and characterristics.

Do not take chances, seek for professional assistance! Please contact us at info@escsteelstructures.com visit our website www.escescsteelstructures.com.